&author.jht; Windows interoperability IDMAP Windows Security IdentifiersSID SID UID GID The Microsoft Windows operating system has a number of features that impose specific challenges to interoperability with the operating systems on which Samba is implemented. This chapter deals explicitly with the mechanisms Samba-3 (version 3.0.8 and later) uses to overcome one of the key challenges in the integration of Samba servers into an MS Windows networking environment. This chapter deals with identity mapping (IDMAP) of Windows security identifiers (SIDs) to UNIX UIDs and GIDs. To ensure sufficient coverage, each possible Samba deployment type is discussed. This is followed by an overview of how the IDMAP facility may be implemented. network client IDMAP IDMAP infrastructure default behavior The IDMAP facility is of concern where more than one Samba server (or Samba network client) is installed in a domain. Where there is a single Samba server, do not be too concerned regarding the IDMAP infrastructure &smbmdash; the default behavior of Samba is nearly always sufficient. Where mulitple Samba servers are used it is often necessary to move data off one server and onto another, and that is where the fun begins! UID GID LDAP NSS nss_ldap NT4 domain members ADS domain members security name-space Where user and group account information is stored in an LDAP directory every server can have the same consistent UID and GID for users and groups. This is achieved using NSS and the nss_ldap tool. Samba can be configured to use only local accounts, in which case the scope of the IDMAP problem is somewhat reduced. This works reasonably well if the servers belong to a single domain, and interdomain trusts are not needed. On the other hand, if the Samba servers are NT4 domain members, or ADS domain members, or if there is a need to keep the security name-space separate (i.e., the user DOMINICUS\FJones must not be given access to the account resources of the user FRANCISCUS\FJonesSamba local account mode results in both DOMINICUS\FJones and FRANCISCUS\FJones mapping to the UNIX user FJones. free from inadvertent cross-over, close attention should be given to the way that the IDMAP facility is configured. IDMAP domain access SID UID GID one domain The use of IDMAP is important where the Samba server will be accessed by workstations or servers from more than one domain, in which case it is important to run winbind so it can handle the resolution (ID mapping) of foreign SIDs to local UNIX UIDs and GIDs. winbindd The use of the IDMAP facility requires the execution of the winbindd upon Samba startup. Server Types There are four basic server deployment types, as documented in the chapter on Server Types and Security Modes. stand-alone server Active Directory NT4 Domain A standalone Samba server is an implementation that is not a member of a Windows NT4 domain, a Windows 200X Active Directory domain, or a Samba domain. IDMAP identity local user By definition, this means that users and groups will be created and controlled locally, and the identity of a network user must match a local UNIX/Linux user login. The IDMAP facility is therefore of little to no interest, winbind will not be necessary, and the IDMAP facility will not be relevant or of interest. PDC BDC NT4 SID Active Directory Samba-3 can act as a Windows NT4 PDC or BDC, thereby providing domain control protocols that are compatible with Windows NT4. Samba-3 file and print sharing protocols are compatible with all versions of MS Windows products. Windows NT4, as with MS Active Directory, extensively makes use of Windows SIDs. MS Windows SID UID GID Samba-3 domain member servers and clients must interact correctly with MS Windows SIDs. Incoming Windows SIDs must be translated to local UNIX UIDs and GIDs. Outgoing information from the Samba server must provide to MS Windows clients and servers appropriate SIDs. ADS winbind A Samba member of a Windows networking domain (NT4-style or ADS) can be configured to handle identity mapping in a variety of ways. The mechanism it uses depends on whether or not the winbindd daemon is used and how the winbind functionality is configured. The configuration options are briefly described here: Winbind is not used; users and groups are local: winbindd smbd network traffic LoginID account name getpwnam NSS local users local groups /etc/passwd /etc/group Where winbindd is not used Samba (smbd) uses the underlying UNIX/Linux mechanisms to resolve the identity of incoming network traffic. This is done using the LoginID (account name) in the session setup request and passing it to the getpwnam() system function call. This call is implemented using the name service switch (NSS) mechanism on modern UNIX/Linux systems. By saying "users and groups are local," we are implying that they are stored only on the local system, in the /etc/passwd and /etc/group respectively. SessionSetupAndX /etc/passwd For example, when the user BERYLIUM\WambatW tries to open a connection to a Samba server the incoming SessionSetupAndX request will make a system call to look up the user WambatW in the /etc/passwd file. standalone domain member server NT4 ADS PDC smbpasswd tdbsam passdb backend This configuration may be used with standalone Samba servers, domain member servers (NT4 or ADS), and for a PDC that uses either an smbpasswd or a tdbsam-based Samba passdb backend. Winbind is not used; users and groups resolved via NSS: user accounts group accounts local accounts repository NIS LDAP In this situation user and group accounts are treated as if they are local accounts. The only way in which this differs from having local accounts is that the accounts are stored in a repository that can be shared. In practice this means that they will reside in either an NIS-type database or else in LDAP. standalone domain member server NT4 ADS PDC smbpasswd tdbsam This configuration may be used with standalone Samba servers, domain member servers (NT4 or ADS), and for a PDC that uses either an smbpasswd or a tdbsam-based Samba passdb backend. Winbind/NSS with the default local IDMAP table: NT4 domain ADS domain winbind domain control There are many sites that require only a simple Samba server or a single Samba server that is a member of a Windows NT4 domain or an ADS domain. A typical example is an appliance like file server on which no local accounts are configured and winbind is used to obtain account credentials from the domain controllers for the domain. The domain control can be provided by Samba-3, MS Windows NT4, or MS Windows Active Directory. UID numbers GID numbers /etc/nsswitch.conf winbind SID Winbind is a great convenience in this situation. All that is needed is a range of UID numbers and GID numbers that can be defined in the &smb.conf; file. The /etc/nsswitch.conf file is configured to use winbind, which does all the difficult work of mapping incoming SIDs to appropriate UIDs and GIDs. The SIDs are allocated a UID/GID in the order in which winbind receives them. UID GID IDMAP corrupted file This configuration is not convenient or practical in sites that have more than one Samba server and that require the same UID or GID for the same user or group across all servers. One of the hazards of this method is that in the event that the winbind IDMAP file becomes corrupted or lost, the repaired or rebuilt IDMAP file may allocate UIDs and GIDs to different users and groups from what was there previously with the result that MS Windows files that are stored on the Samba server may now not belong to the rightful owners. Winbind/NSS uses RID based IDMAP: RID idmap_rid ADS LDAP The IDMAP_RID facility is new to Samba version 3.0.8. It was added to make life easier for a number of sites that are committed to use of MS ADS, that do not apply an ADS schema extension, and that do not have an installed an LDAP directory server just for the purpose of maintaining an IDMAP table. If you have a single ADS domain (not a forest of domains, and not multiple domain trees) and you want a simple cookie-cutter solution to the IDMAP table problem, then IDMAP_RID is an obvious choice. idmap_rid idmap uid idmap gid RID SID UID idmap backend automatic mapping This facility requires the allocation of the idmap uid and the idmap gid ranges, and within the idmap uid it is possible to allocate a subset of this range for automatic mapping of the relative identifier (RID) portion of the SID directly to the base of the UID plus the RID value. For example, if the idmap uid range is 1000-100000000 and the idmap backend = idmap_rid:DOMAIN_NAME=1000-50000000, and a SID is encountered that has the value S-1-5-21-34567898-12529001-32973135-1234, the resulting UID will be 1000 + 1234 = 2234. Winbind with an NSS/LDAP backend-based IDMAP facility: Domain Member winbind SID UID GID idmap gid idmap uid LDAP In this configuration winbind resolved SIDs to UIDs and GIDs from the idmap uid and idmap gid ranges specified in the &smb.conf; file, but instead of using a local winbind IDMAP table, it is stored in an LDAP directory so that all domain member machines (clients and servers) can share a common IDMAP table. idmap backend LDAP server LDAP redirects It is important that all LDAP IDMAP clients use only the master LDAP server because the idmap backend facility in the &smb.conf; file does not correctly handle LDAP redirects. Winbind with NSS to resolve UNIX/Linux user and group IDs: The use of LDAP as the passdb backend is a smart solution for PDC, BDC, and domain member servers. It is a neat method for assuring that UIDs, GIDs, and the matching SIDs are consistent across all servers. LDAP PADL The use of the LDAP-based passdb backend requires use of the PADL nss_ldap utility or an equivalent. In this situation winbind is used to handle foreign SIDs, that is, SIDs from standalone Windows clients (i.e., not a member of our domain) as well as SIDs from another domain. The foreign UID/GID is mapped from allocated ranges (idmap uid and idmap gid) in precisely the same manner as when using winbind with a local IDMAP table. nss_ldap AD4UNIX MMC The nss_ldap tool set can be used to access UIDs and GIDs via LDAP as well as via Active Directory. In order to use Active Directory, it is necessary to modify the ADS schema by installing either the AD4UNIX schema extension or using the Microsoft Services for UNIX version 3.5 or later to extend the ADS schema so it maintains UNIX account credentials. Where the ADS schema is extended, a Microsoft Management Console (MMC) snap-in is also installed to permit the UNIX credentials to be set and managed from the ADS User and Computer Management tool. Each account must be separately UNIX-enabled before the UID and GID data can be used by Samba. domain security SID RID algorithmic mapping Microsoft Windows domain security systems generate the user and group SID as part of the process of creation of an account. Windows does not have a concept of the UNIX UID or a GID; rather, it has its own type of security descriptor. When Samba is used as a domain controller, it provides a method of producing a unique SID for each user and group. Samba generates a machine and a domain SID to which it adds an RID that is calculated algorithmically from a base value that can be specified in the &smb.conf; file, plus twice (2x) the UID or GID. This method is called algorithmic mapping. RID base For example, if a user has a UID of 4321, and the algorithmic RID base has a value of 1000, the RID will be 1000 + (2 x 4321) = 9642. Thus, if the domain SID is S-1-5-21-89238497-92787123-12341112, the resulting SID is S-1-5-21-89238497-92787123-12341112-9642. on-the-fly SID passdb backend ldapsam The foregoing type of SID is produced by Samba as an automatic function and is either produced on the fly (as is the case when using a passdb backend = [tdbsam | smbpasswd]), or may be stored as a permanent part of an account in an LDAP-based ldapsam. SFU 3.5 ADS directory schema account attributes UID GID ADS schema account management MMC ADS uses a directory schema that can be extended to accommodate additional account attributes such as UIDs and GIDs. The installation of Microsoft Service for UNIX 3.5 will expand the normal ADS schema to include UNIX account attributes. These must of course be managed separately through a snap-in module to the normal ADS account management MMC interface. PDC passdb backend BDC LDAP backend Security identifiers used within a domain must be managed to avoid conflict and to preserve itegrity. In an NT4 domain context, the PDC manages the distribution of all security credentials to the backup domain controllers (BDCs). At this time the only passdb backend for a Samba domain controller that is suitable for such information is an LDAP backend. BDC read-only access security credentials LDAP group account write changes directory BDCs have read-only access to security credentials that are stored in LDAP. Changes in user or group account information are passed by the BDC to the PDC. Only the PDC can write changes to the directory. IDMAP information can be written directly to the LDAP server so long as all domain controllers have access to the master (writable) LDAP server. Samba-3 at this time does not handle LDAP redirects in the IDMAP backend. This means that it is is unsafe to use a slave (replicate) LDAP server with the IDMAP facility. Domain Member ServerDMS Domain Member ClientDMC DMS DMC winbind Anyone who wishes to use winbind will find the following example configurations helpful. Remember that in the majority of cases winbind is of primary interest for use with domain member servers (DMSs) and domain member clients (DMCs). Two common configurations are used: Networks that have an NT4 PDC (with or without BDCs) or a Samba PDC (with or without BDCs). Networks that use MS Windows 200x ADS. The following is a simple example of an NT4 DMS &smb.conf; file that shows only the global section. #Global parameters [global] workgroup = MEGANET2 security = DOMAIN idmap uid = 10000-20000 idmap gid = 10000-20000 template primary group = "Domain Users" template shell = /bin/bash winbind /etc/nsswitch.conf The use of winbind requires configuration of NSS. Edit the /etc/nsswitch.conf so it includes the following entries: ... passwd: files winbind shadow: files winbind group: files winbind ... hosts: files [dns] wins ... The use of DNS in the hosts entry should be made only if DNS is used on site. The creation of the DMS requires the following steps: Create or install an &smb.conf; file with the above configuration. Execute: &rootprompt; net rpc join -UAdministrator%password Joined domain MEGANET2. join The success of the join can be confirmed with the following command: &rootprompt; net rpc testjoin Join to 'MIDEARTH' is OK A failed join would report an error message like the following: failed join &rootprompt; net rpc testjoin [2004/11/05 16:34:12, 0] utils/net_rpc_join.c:net_rpc_join_ok(66) Join to domain 'MEGANET2' is not valid nmbd winbind smbd Start the nmbd, winbind, and smbd daemons in the order shown. domain join ADS domain The procedure for joining an ADS domain is similar to the NT4 domain join, except the &smb.conf; file will have the following contents: # Global parameters [global] workgroup = BUTTERNET netbios name = GARGOYLE realm = BUTTERNET.BIZ security = ADS template shell = /bin/bash idmap uid = 500-10000000 idmap gid = 500-10000000 winbind use default domain = Yes winbind nested groups = Yes printer admin = "BUTTERNET\Domain Admins" KRB kerberos /etc/krb5.conf MIT MIT kerberos Heimdal Heimdal kerberos ADS DMS operation requires use of kerberos (KRB). For this to work, the krb5.conf must be configured. The exact requirements depends on which version of MIT or Heimdal Kerberos is being used. It is sound advice to use only the latest version, which at this time are MIT Kerberos version 1.3.5 and Heimdal 0.61. The creation of the DMS requires the following steps: Create or install an &smb.conf; file with the above configuration. Edit the /etc/nsswitch.conf file as shown above. Execute: netadsjoin &rootprompt; net ads join -UAdministrator%password Joined domain BUTTERNET. The success or failure of the join can be confirmed with the following command: &rootprompt; net ads testjoin Using short domain name -- BUTTERNET Joined 'GARGOYLE' to realm 'BUTTERNET.BIZ' An invalid or failed join can be detected by executing: &rootprompt; net ads testjoin GARGOYLE$@'s password: [2004/11/05 16:53:03, 0] utils/net_ads.c:ads_startup(186) ads_connect: No results returned Join to domain is not valid error message failure log level identify The specific error message may differ from the above because it depends on the type of failure that may have occurred. Increase the log level to 10, repeat the test, and then examine the log files produced to identify the nature of the failure. Start the nmbd, winbind, and smbd daemons in the order shown. idmap_rid SID RID IDMAP The idmap_rid facility is a new tool that, unlike native winbind, creates a predictable mapping of MS Windows SIDs to UNIX UIDs and GIDs. The key benefit of this method of implementing the Samba IDMAP facility is that it eliminates the need to store the IDMAP data in a central place. The downside is that it can be used only within a single ADS domain and is not compatible with trusted domain implementations. SID allow trusted domains idmap uid idmap gid This alternate method of SID to UID/GID mapping can be achieved using the idmap_rid plug-in. This plug-in uses the RID of the user SID to derive the UID and GID by adding the RID to a base value specified. This utility requires that the parameter allow trusted domains = No be specified, as it is not compatible with multiple domain environments. The idmap uid and idmap gid ranges must be specified. idmap_rid realm The idmap_rid facility can be used both for NT4/Samba-style domains and Active Directory. To use this with an NT4 domain, do not include the realm parameter; additionally, the method used to join the domain uses the net rpc join process. An example &smb.conf; file for and ADS domain environment is shown here: # Global parameters [global] workgroup = KPAK netbios name = BIGJOE realm = CORP.KPAK.COM server string = Office Server security = ADS allow trusted domains = No idmap backend = idmap_rid:KPAK=500-100000000 idmap uid = 500-100000000 idmap gid = 500-100000000 template shell = /bin/bash winbind use default domain = Yes winbind enum users = No winbind enum groups = No winbind nested groups = Yes printer admin = "Domain Admins" large domain Active Directory response getent In a large domain with many users it is imperative to disable enumeration of users and groups. For example, at a site that has 22,000 users in Active Directory the winbind-based user and group resolution is unavailable for nearly 12 minutes following first startup of winbind. Disabling enumeration resulted in instantaneous response. The disabling of user and group enumeration means that it will not be possible to list users or groups using the getent passwd and getent group commands. It will be possible to perform the lookup for individual users, as shown in the following procedure. NSS /etc/nsswitch.conf The use of this tool requires configuration of NSS as per the native use of winbind. Edit the /etc/nsswitch.conf so it has the following parameters: ... passwd: files winbind shadow: files winbind group: files winbind ... hosts: files wins ... The following procedure can use the idmap_rid facility: Create or install an &smb.conf; file with the above configuration. Edit the /etc/nsswitch.conf file as shown above. Execute: &rootprompt; net ads join -UAdministrator%password Using short domain name -- KPAK Joined 'BIGJOE' to realm 'CORP.KPAK.COM' failed join An invalid or failed join can be detected by executing: &rootprompt; net ads testjoin BIGJOE$@'s password: [2004/11/05 16:53:03, 0] utils/net_ads.c:ads_startup(186) ads_connect: No results returned Join to domain is not valid The specific error message may differ from the above because it depends on the type of failure that may have occurred. Increase the log level to 10, repeat the test, and then examine the log files produced to identify the nature of the failure. Start the nmbd, winbind, and smbd daemons in the order shown. Validate the operation of this configuration by executing: &rootprompt; getent passwd administrator administrator:x:1000:1013:Administrator:/home/BE/administrator:/bin/bash ADAM ADS The storage of IDMAP information in LDAP can be used with both NT4/Samba-3-style domains and ADS domains. OpenLDAP is a commonly used LDAP server for this purpose, although any standards-complying LDAP server can be used. It is therefore possible to deploy this IDMAP configuration using the Sun iPlanet LDAP server, Novell eDirectory, Microsoft ADS plus ADAM, and so on. The following example is for an ADS domain: # Global parameters [global] workgroup = SNOWSHOW netbios name = GOODELF realm = SNOWSHOW.COM server string = Samba Server security = ADS log level = 1 ads:10 auth:10 sam:10 rpc:10 ldap admin dn = cn=Manager,dc=SNOWSHOW,dc=COM ldap idmap suffix = ou=Idmap ldap suffix = dc=SNOWSHOW,dc=COM idmap backend = ldap:ldap://ldap.snowshow.com idmap uid = 150000-550000 idmap gid = 150000-550000 template shell = /bin/bash winbind use default domain = Yes realm In the case of an NT4 or Samba-3-style domain the realm is not used, and the command used to join the domain is net rpc join. The above example also demonstrates advanced error-reporting techniques that are documented in Reporting Bugs. MIT kerberos Heimdal kerberos /etc/krb5.conf Where MIT kerberos is installed (version 1.3.4 or later), edit the /etc/krb5.conf file so it has the following contents: [logging] default = FILE:/var/log/krb5libs.log kdc = FILE:/var/log/krb5kdc.log admin_server = FILE:/var/log/kadmind.log [libdefaults] default_realm = SNOWSHOW.COM dns_lookup_realm = false dns_lookup_kdc = true [appdefaults] pam = { debug = false ticket_lifetime = 36000 renew_lifetime = 36000 forwardable = true krb4_convert = false } Where Heimdal kerberos is installed, edit the /etc/krb5.conf file so it is either empty (i.e., no contents) or it has the following contents: [libdefaults] default_realm = SNOWSHOW.COM clockskew = 300 [realms] SNOWSHOW.COM = { kdc = ADSDC.SHOWSHOW.COM } [domain_realm] .snowshow.com = SNOWSHOW.COM Samba cannot use the Heimdal libraries if there is no /etc/krb5.conf file. So long as there is an empty file, the Heimdal kerberos libraries will be usable. There is no need to specify any settings because Samba, using the Heimdal libraries, can figure this out automatically. Edit the NSS control file /etc/nsswitch.conf so it has the following entries: ... passwd: files ldap shadow: files ldap group: files ldap ... hosts: files wins ... PADL /etc/ldap.conf You will need the PADL nss_ldap tool set for this solution. Configure the /etc/ldap.conf file so it has the information needed. The following is an example of a working file: host 192.168.2.1 base dc=snowshow,dc=com binddn cn=Manager,dc=snowshow,dc=com bindpw not24get pam_password exop nss_base_passwd ou=People,dc=snowshow,dc=com?one nss_base_shadow ou=People,dc=snowshow,dc=com?one nss_base_group ou=Groups,dc=snowshow,dc=com?one ssl no The following procedure may be followed to effect a working configuration: Configure the &smb.conf; file as shown above. Create the /etc/krb5.conf file as shown above. Configure the /etc/nsswitch.conf file as shown above. Download, build, and install the PADL nss_ldap tool set. Configure the /etc/ldap.conf file as shown above. Configure an LDAP server and initialize the directory with the top-level entries needed by IDMAP, shown in the following LDIF file: dn: dc=snowshow,dc=com objectClass: dcObject objectClass: organization dc: snowshow o: The Greatest Snow Show in Singapore. description: Posix and Samba LDAP Identity Database dn: cn=Manager,dc=snowshow,dc=com objectClass: organizationalRole cn: Manager description: Directory Manager dn: ou=Idmap,dc=snowshow,dc=com objectClass: organizationalUnit ou: idmap Execute the command to join the Samba DMS to the ADS domain as shown here: &rootprompt; net ads testjoin Using short domain name -- SNOWSHOW Joined 'GOODELF' to realm 'SNOWSHOW.COM' Store the LDAP server access password in the Samba secrets.tdb file as follows: &rootprompt; smbpasswd -w not24get Start the nmbd, winbind, and smbd daemons in the order shown. diagnostic Follow the diagnositic procedures shown earlier in this chapter to identify success or failure of the join. In many cases a failure is indicated by a silent return to the command prompt with no indication of the reason for failure. rfc2307bis schema The use of this method is messy. The information provided in the following is for guidance only and is very definitely not complete. This method does work; it is used in a number of large sites and has an acceptable level of performance. The following is an example &smb.conf; file: # Global parameters [global] workgroup = BOBBY realm = BOBBY.COM security = ADS idmap uid = 150000-550000 idmap gid = 150000-550000 template shell = /bin/bash winbind cache time = 5 winbind use default domain = Yes winbind trusted domains only = Yes winbind nested groups = Yes nss_ldap The DMS must be joined to the domain using the usual procedure. Additionally, it is necessary to build and install the PADL nss_ldap tool set. Be sure to build this tool set with the following: ./configure --enable-rfc2307bis --enable-schema-mapping make install /etc/nsswitch.conf The following /etc/nsswitch.conf file contents are required: ... passwd: files ldap shadow: files ldap group: files ldap ... hosts: files wins ... /etc/ldap.conf nss_ldap The /etc/ldap.conf file must be configured also. Refer to the PADL documentation and source code for nss_ldap to specific instructions. The next step involves preparation of the ADS schema. This is briefly discussed in the remaining part of this chapter. SFU The Microsoft Windows Service for UNIX (SFU) version 3.5 is available for free download from the Microsoft Web site. You will need to download this tool and install it following Microsoft instructions. Instructions for obtaining and installing the AD4UNIX tool set can be found from the Geekcomix Web site.